1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Curious about veganism or vegetarianism? Why not ask us a question? (You don't have to sign up, or be vegan or vegetarian!)
    Dismiss Notice

Linguistics "Understanding African-American English"

Discussion in 'Social Sciences & Humanities' started by Spang, Jul 11, 2012.

Image has been removed.
URL has been removed.
Email address has been removed.
Media has been removed.
  1. Spang

    Spang Foot Fetisher

    Read it all here.
     
  2. Indian Summer

    Indian Summer Administrator Owner

    It makes sense to categorize it as a dialect, I think. Especially because I don't understand what is said half the time. It's the same with the language spoken in the US South. I went to the cinema to watch No country for old men without subtitles. That was one of the most frustrating movie experiences in my life! It's just not the kind of English we were taught in school.
     
  3. jeneticallymodified

    jeneticallymodified Veteran Member

    Location:
    Canada
    it is very complicated. i love the sounds of dialects, as well as pidgin and creole languages- but they sometimes make me a smidgen uncomfortable, because not speaking standard english fluently, really closes a lot of doors to people. :(
     
  4. mlp

    mlp Guest

    That was interesting - I didn't know about the "habitual be" construction.
     
  5. das_nut

    das_nut World Class Member

    Aye.

    Then again, "standard" English has enough variation that both the written and spoken word will have differences depending on the standard being used.

    Here's some examples of differences between British English and American English: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_American_and_British_English

    Of course, even the age of the speaker or the source also affects what is considered proper.
     
  6. nigel

    nigel Veteran Member

    Location:
    France
    So-called Ebonics have been argued to have rules that would make a distinct dialect. I haven't seen much in terms of a similar argument on US southern accents. Texas isn't the South, BTW. It's Texas.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  7. cornsail

    cornsail Renowned Member

    Thank you for posting that. Yes, African American and Southern American dialects have slightly different rules, which are used just as consistently by speakers as "standard English" speakers use their grammatical rules.

    It annoys me when people describe other the use of other dialects as "uneducated", "ignorant", "stupid", "incorrect", etc. They are just different. As jeneticallymodified pointed out, though, it is a disadvantage to grow up with a "non-standard" dialect.
     
  8. nigel

    nigel Veteran Member

    Location:
    France
    Do you see "Southern" as a dialect? I haven't seen much of an argument for that and am curious. I've always seen it as more of just a a collection of somewhat distinct accents.
     
  9. cornsail

    cornsail Renowned Member

    The distinction of "you" (singular), "y'all" (plural) and "all y'all" (all-inclusive plural) is an example. I don't know that much about southern dialects, but it's on wiki: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_American_English
     
  10. jeneticallymodified

    jeneticallymodified Veteran Member

    Location:
    Canada
    i deal with this on a daily basis- as a brit, trying to make myself understood in canada. :p


    it's a whole quagmire of somewhat distinct accents. y'all. :p :yes:
     
  11. jeneticallymodified

    jeneticallymodified Veteran Member

    Location:
    Canada
    my local accent from back home (somerset) marks me as being a drunken yokel farmer, by people from other regions. the usual response when i say where i'm from is the other party saying "i can't read and i can't write, but i can drive a tractor" very enthusiastically. :p my dad's regional accent (same as ozzy ozzbourne's) is perceived by the majority of brits as making the speaker sound like a complete wazzock... as he was ex-forces and had his accent drilled out of him, i was constantly told to 'speak properly' as a child... and i'm relatively appreciative of it these days- if i lapse into speaking like the kids i grew up with (which i do sometimes, when i'm on the phone with them) nobody here has a clue what i'm saying. :D

    regional dialects and accents are dying in the UK. we'll miss them when they're gone. :(
     
  12. das_nut

    das_nut World Class Member

    Speaking of BritEng, I always pictured lorries as some sort of large weird creature. Furry, probably yellowish colored, and possibly capable of flight. They seem to be capable of carrying things, after all. They may swoop down on roads and frighten drivers of small cars. ;)

    Oh, and I was reading a book by a British author that took place (partially) in the US. One of the characters was driving around and it mentioned looking for "for sale"/"to let" signs. Not something you'd ever see in this neck of the woods, but I don't know about Canadian English.
     
  13. das_nut

    das_nut World Class Member

    Wait, for Ozzy, that's an accent? I always figured it was speech impairment due to years of heavy drinking and drug abuse.
     
  14. jeneticallymodified

    jeneticallymodified Veteran Member

    Location:
    Canada
    my bf is quite insistent that 'lorry is a girls name' ('laurie'- shortened form of laura?).

    'to let' is 'for rent'. :D you let people live there. they pay you. :D mature people draw a letter 'i' in the middle of those signs. :D

    he does seem to have a degree of alcoholic brain damage, and a stutter, but yes- he has a very thick brummie/black country accent. they say things beautifully... 'a cup of tea' is said 'a kipper tie', for example. :D

    if you want to try and speak like a brummie yourself (and/or understand what the hell they're saying :D), this'll help:

    http://www.h2g2.com/approved_entry/A496352
     
  15. das_nut

    das_nut World Class Member

    So does Canadian English default to "to let" or "for rent"? I'm curious now.

    And I don't need help to speak like a brummie. Just get me some ice, gin and tonic water. I'll do the rest. :p
     
  16. beancounter

    beancounter The Fire That Burns Within Forum Moderator

    By telling people that using this "dialects" is OK, you are causing them more harm than good. By encouraging them to continue using it instead of making an effort to learn standard English, may give you the warm and fuzzies, and may make the minority feel good about himself, but it is equivelant to giving a kid a trophy when he didn't win.

    If you want to help minorities break the cycle of poverty, and allow them to grow to their potential, validating this dialect will not accomplish that goal. As a matter of fact, by doing so, you are contributing to the cycle of poverty.

    Reality Check:
    If an employer has the choice between two candidates, and one uses standard English, and the other uses the "Ebonics" dialect, which one do you suppose the employer is more likely to choose?
     
    • Like Like x 2
  17. ElaineV

    ElaineV Guest

    It may not be an advantage in most workplaces like American Sign Language. But also like ASL African-American English is a language.
     
  18. cornsail

    cornsail Renowned Member

    The existence of other languages and dialects is simply a fact. It remains so whether or not we choose to "validate" them or declare them "ok".

    Studies have shown that if employers have the choice between a candidate with a "standard" English name such as "John" and an minority-sounding name such as "Jamal" they will be more like to choose the person with the "standard" name. I get that for pragmatic reasons, pleasing employers is important, even when it relates to prejudices that aren't entirely rational, but I think that's different than outright calling such disadvantageous cultural differences "not okay" or "invalid". Although I'd encourage everyone to learn to speak and write "standard" English for personal advancement if necessary, I'd also like to see more employers realize that alternative speech patterns do not necessarily have anything to do with stupidity or slang.
     
  19. beancounter

    beancounter The Fire That Burns Within Forum Moderator

    Of course it's a fact, but by saying it's Ok to use it, you are essentially telling them that they don't have to improve, validating their station in life as acceptable.

    Giving the loser a trophy when he didn't win may make him feel good about himself, but it doesn't do anything to help him do better the next time he plays the game. He will continue to lose because he's been convinced by the coddlers that his game is good enough.

    And at the end of the day, pragmatism is all that matters when you want to put food on the table.
     
  20. Spang

    Spang Foot Fetisher

    Are you suggesting that people who speak with an English dialect are losers?
     
    • Like Like x 2
Loading...
Similar Threads - Understanding African American
  1. rainforests1
    Replies:
    13
    Views:
    460
  2. Lord Snot
    Replies:
    3
    Views:
    416